You can negotiate PhD offers. Within limits, politely, with competing offers as leverage.
What is negotiable: fellowship top-ups, an extra funded year, guaranteed summer funding, moving expenses, and early research assistant placement. Base stipends are rarely negotiable (union tables, equity rules), but the package around them is.
Tools that help:
- Competing offer letters: the only leverage that matters.
- Cost-of-living data: for the your-stipend-buys-less-here conversation.
- Union contract tables: know the floor before you ask.
- A one-page comparison sheet: shows you did homework.
How to ask: Program X offered a fellowship year; is there flexibility on summer funding here? Gracious, specific, and easy to say yes to.
Get any negotiated extras in the updated offer letter; verbal promises evaporate. Sources: PhD Stipends Negotiate after admission, before April 15 (the common reply deadline). And never bluff with an offer you would not accept; small fields have long memories.